Beignet Brew sat on a Mid-City corner where the streetcar line and the school run both did their worst around five o'clock, and by half past the early crowd had thinned to a few students with laptops and a man in a neon vest eating a savoury turnover over the sports page. The air smelled of chicory, fried dough and brown butter. Behind the glass case a chalkboard listed the day's new recipes in cheerful, slanting chalk, one of them involving crawfish and a hot pepper jelly that Odalys had read three times without once deciding she would be brave enough. Powdered sugar had drifted across the counter and onto the floor in a fine white tide, and every few minutes the door bell sounded and somebody tracked it further in.
She had taken a four-top at the back, away from the window, and then spent a minute deciding where to sit at it. In the end she put herself on the side with her back to the room and left the chair facing the door empty, her bag on the floor beside her own chair and the table kept clear on his side. It was a small courtesy, and she was aware that it might also read as a presumption. She had decided that was a risk worth taking over making a man spend an hour with his shoulders to a stranger.
The request had gone out on Monday, and she had written it four times. She was not, as she had put it in the final draft, a friend of the department or an enemy of it. She represented an officer facing separation after an infection contracted in the line of duty, in a matter that was adverse to the department he served, and she wanted to understand how a different officer in the same position had actually been handled. She had been plain that Detective Blackchapel owed her nothing. She had suggested he speak to his union representative before he spoke to her, if he had one. She had said that nothing would be written down or attributed without his agreement in writing, that he could end the conversation at any point, and that she would understand if he preferred not to answer at all. His reply had arrived on Tuesday night, a single line of text with a time and the name of this place.
A person who agrees that quickly either has nothing to hide or has been waiting years for someone to ask. I won't know which until he sits down, and I must not behave as though I do.
On the table lay a plain folder and a legal pad, and beneath the pad a single typed page she had brought in case it was wanted: a short consent form, three paragraphs, with a line for his signature that she did not intend to ask him to use today. She had a coffee she had not touched. She had thought of ordering a second one for him and decided against it, since she could not tell whether it would read as hospitality or as an attempt to put him in her debt.
What she wanted from him was not complicated, only difficult to ask for. She wanted to know what had actually happened after the diagnosis, as opposed to what the department's policy said should happen: who had been told first, what had been put in writing and what had not, whether anybody had made him a promise he later found was worth nothing. Policy covered separation and said very little about staying. The carve-out gave the department a right to end a career over infection without obliging it to, which meant that somewhere, in some precinct, a decision had once been made to keep a man on, and the paperwork would not say why. She suspected that decision had turned on a person rather than a rule. If it had, her client's case looked quite different, and she needed to know which way it cut before anyone else did.
Despacio, Odalys. He had not agreed to relive anything. He had agreed to a conversation, and if he walked out halfway through it she would take her notes and her coffee and wish him a good evening. She straightened the pad until its edge ran true with the table, turned her cup a quarter turn on its saucer, and watched the door.