The argument had begun, as arguments with Merewyn tended to begin, with a letter.
She had written three weeks prior, neat and purposeful in the hand she had inherited from her mother and the directness she had inherited from him, requesting a meeting at his earliest convenience regarding Osian's future prospects. He had replied briefly that his availability was limited and that she was welcome to come to Caer Glosterre if the matter was urgent. She had apparently decided it was urgent because she had arrived that morning without further warning, which was also inherited.
She was forty-one, Merewyn Hale that was, Merewyn Croft by marriage, and she had the family's colouring, dark and weathered at the edges from a life spent largely outdoors, and her grandmother's jaw set at the angle it assumed when she had decided something and was waiting for the world to catch up. She was not a tall woman, but she carried herself as though she was, which Hale had long suspected was a deliberate decision rather than a natural quality, and she was dressed for travel rather than court in a wool coat of deep green that had seen several winters and showed it with a certain unapologetic honesty.
She had her father's hands, large-knuckled and capable, and she was currently using them to grip the back of the chair in front of his desk in the manner of a woman who had decided the chair was a more appropriate recipient of her present feelings than the man across from it.
Hale stood at the window. He had not sat down since she arrived, which was either a professional habit or an instinctive recognition that sitting would make him feel at a disadvantage, and he had his hands behind his back in the manner she had known since childhood and had always privately considered his fighting stance, the stance of a man settling his weight before something required holding.
He was, she had noted upon arrival and noted again now, in better condition than she had seen him in some years. Not younger, precisely, the grey at his temples had not retreated, and the lines around his eyes had not softened, but there was something less set about him than usual, some quality of the jaw and the shoulders that suggested a man who had, recently and without apparent explanation, put something down.
She had filed this observation and intended to return to it.
"He is seventeen, Idris. Seventeen, with his father's constitution and his grandfather's record and every qualification your people require, and you are telling me to send him back to the Marches and wait?"
"I am telling you," Hale said, with the flat patience of a man who has been saying the same thing for twenty minutes and has not yet found a phrasing that produces the desired result, "that the candidacy intake is in four months and that Osian's application will receive the same consideration as every other candidate's application, which is the only consideration I am able to offer him without compromising his standing before he has even begun."
"The same consideration." She said it in the tone of a woman examining a phrase and finding it structurally unsound, releasing the chair back and straightening to her full height, which was not inconsiderable when she remembered to use it. "His uncle is the High Marshal and he will receive the same consideration as a boy from the lower valleys whose father swept the stables. You are telling me this as though it is a virtue."
"It is a virtue," Hale said. "Ask any man in this building whether he would prefer his record or his connections to speak for him and see which answer you receive."
"I am not asking any man in this building." She had moved to the window on the opposite side of the room, which meant they were now conducting the argument across its full width, which she had apparently decided was the appropriate geography for it. "I am asking you."
"Then you have your answer."
She made a sound through her nose that their mother had also made, a short and comprehensive dismissal of a position she found inadequate, and turned from the window to look at him with the directness that was entirely, unmistakably familial. She tilted her head as she had since she was small, the slight leftward angle of a woman examining something from a different perspective to determine whether it improved.
It apparently did not.
"You have been in better temper lately," she said, and the shift in register was the shift of a woman who has assessed the available terrain and identified a different approach. "I noticed it when I arrived. You looked," she studied him with the frank attention of someone who has known a face for forty years and reads it accordingly, "like a man who has recently had something to think about beyond the northern passes and the border reports."
"Merewyn."
"I am simply making an observation."
"You are deflecting."
"So are you." She crossed her arms over her chest, which was a gesture he recognised from the mirror, and looked at him with the expression of a woman settling in for a longer conversation than the one they had been having. "Osian is a good boy, Idris. He is steady, and he is serious, and he has wanted nothing else since he was old enough to watch the wings fly over the Marches. I am not asking you to hand him anything. I am asking you to tell me honestly whether the four months can be reduced to two."
He opened his mouth.
The door to the outer office, which his adjutant had left not quite fully closed with the self-preserving instinct of a man who had heard the opening exchange and correctly identified it as above his remit, swung a fraction further on its hinges in the draught from the corridor beyond.